In 2020, a remarkable discovery was made in the gallery above the Notre Dame de Paris nave: long-lost stained glass panels dating from 1935. These fragments were sent to the Manufacture Vincent Petit for analysis, reigniting interest in a lesser-known chapter of the cathedral's history.
In the 1930s, stained glass artist Louis Baillet was tasked with selecting artists for Notre Dame's new stained glass windows. However, the project faced resistance. The 19th-century Viollet-le-Duc windows were criticized for being too pale and not aligning with the cathedral's Gothic aesthetic. Despite these challenges, twelve artists took on the project, funding much of it themselves in hopes of leaving a lasting mark on one of the world’s most iconic landmarks.
The artists exhibited their designs at the Pontifical Pavilion in 1937 to garner support, yet the Commission for Historical Monuments rejected them, citing design, proportion, and color inconsistencies. World War II further derailed the project, leaving much of the work incomplete.
While plans were initially made to replace Viollet-le-Duc’s windows in Notre Dame, including updates to its 13th-century Rose Windows, fragments remain today. Of the original twelve windows, only a few pieces, a complete rose window, and an almost-complete bay survive. Notably, Jacques Le Chevallier’s designs were among the few that were retained and reinstalled in 1965.
Not everyone agreed to replace the VLD windows. Gabriel Rupinich-Robert, Grand Inspector of Historical Monuments, believed they were in fine condition and did not require replacement. Similarly, Aléette de Maille, Vice President of La Sauvegarde de l’Art Français, opposed removing these unique art pieces.
Each artist brought their distinct style and vision to Notre Dame:
Jean Hébert-Stevens initially created figures for Saint Loup & Saint Germain, which were later revised to Saint Radegonde & Saint Martin. His work was accepted but underwent color adjustments.
Valentine Reyre: A key figure in 20th-century sacred art, her works included Saint Foy & Saint Martial.
Louis Mazetier: Designed Saint Bernard and the Holy Ghost rose window.
Father Marie-Alain Couturier: Depicted Saint Clotilde & Saint Germain.
Paul Louzier: Created windows of Saint Francis de Sales & Saint Vianney, later modified to darker colors.
Following the devastating 2019 fire, all stained glass windows were found to be intact, aside from minor damage to the small rose windows due to heat. Restoration efforts began, focusing on cleaning, analyzing, and re-firing the glass using modern techniques. Of the twelve original artists, only works by Le Chevallier and Hébert-Stevens are known to exist today.
Le Chevallier’s family returned one of his windows to Notre Dame in 2013 to commemorate the cathedral’s 850th anniversary, later donating it to the Cité du Vitrail in Troyes. Additionally, crates of never-fired glass panels were discovered post-fire, offering a glimpse into these artists' incomplete vision.
In December 2023, President Emmanuel Macron and Archbishop Laurent Ulrich selected contemporary artist Claire Tabouret to design six new stained glass windows. Tabouret’s work, featuring watercolor-inspired designs with vibrant turquoise, yellow, and red hues, aims to pay homage to the Viollet-le-Duc windows.. The project will be executed by Simon-Marc, one of France’s oldest stained-glass workshops, with a budget of €4 million, funded by the Ministry of Culture.
The new windows of Claire Tabouret
This decision has sparked debate, particularly regarding the 1964 Venice Charter, which stipulates that original artworks integral to a monument should only be removed if it ensures their preservation. While some argue that the new designs will breathe fresh life into Notre Dame, others believe the historical VLD windows should be maintained and restored.
Notre Dame’s stained glass story involves artistic struggle, war-induced delays, and shifting cultural tastes. Whether through preservation or reinvention, these windows reflect the cathedral’s ongoing evolution—a testament to the artists who sought to leave their mark on one of the world’s most treasured landmarks.